A federal judge has ruled that the City of Prattville, Alabama, must allow an LGBTQ+ pride group, Prattville Pride, to participate in the city’s Christmas parade after the group was initially banned by Mayor Bill Gillespie Jr. citing vague “safety concerns.”
U.S. District Judge R. Austin Huffaker Jr. determined the city violated Prattville Pride’s First Amendment right to free speech and 14th Amendment right to equal protection under the law.
In his ruling, Huffaker stated the city acted unlawfully by removing the group based on concerns that some members of the public might oppose the group’s presence and react disruptively. He emphasized, “Discrimination based on a message’s content cannot be tolerated under the First Amendment.”
The judge’s order also required the city to provide at least two police officers to escort the Prattville Pride float during the parade, ensuring their safety.
Prattville Pride celebrated the ruling on social media.
“The Christmas parade is a cherished holiday tradition, and we are excited to celebrate alongside our neighbors and friends in the spirit of love, joy, and unity,” the group wrote.
The controversy began when Prattville Pride requested additional security ahead of the parade, following public opposition to their inclusion. In response, Mayor Gillespie banned the group outright, citing what he described as “serious safety concerns.”
However, Huffaker noted that the city failed to provide evidence of credible threats of physical violence.
In a statement posted on the city’s social media, Gillespie’s office defended its initial decision but has yet to comment further on the judge’s ruling.
“The City respects the ruling of the Court and will comply with its order. The safety of everyone involved with the parade is a priority,” city officials said in a statement on social media.
