Federal Prosecution Could Mean Death Penalty for Accused Killer of UnitedHealthcare CEO

Former Judge Andrew Napolitano told Newsmax on Thursday that Luigi Mangione, the man accused of killing UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson, could face the death penalty if federal prosecutors pursue charges of murder as an act of terrorism. The possibility arises due to the nature of the crime, which might fit federal definitions of terrorism.

On December 11, Mangione, 26, allegedly shot and killed Thompson, 50, outside the New York Hilton Midtown. Currently, Mangione faces charges including one count of murder, two counts of second-degree criminal possession of a weapon, one count of second-degree possession of a forged document, and one count of third-degree criminal possession of a firearm, according to court records.

Napolitano explained that if federal prosecutors decide to take over the case, it would remove jurisdiction from Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg’s office. Mangione appeared in a Pennsylvania court Thursday for a hearing on New York’s extradition request to bring him back to Manhattan for trial.

“I think they’re [federal prosecutors] probably trying to decide whether they want to get involved,” Napolitano said during the “Wake Up America” segment on Newsmax. “They usually don’t get involved in cases like this. Even though this was planned and plotted and lying in wait. And it’s a classic first-degree murder.”

The potential for federal involvement stems from the assertion that Mangione’s actions were intended to intimidate or terrify the public, which could categorize the crime as an act of terrorism. If federal prosecutors charge Mangione under this classification, it opens the possibility of capital punishment.

“Even though the state says he did this in order to intimidate and terrify the civilian population, this is not a typical case for the federal government to get involved. But if they do, the death penalty is available,” Napolitano explained.

The killing of Brian Thompson shocked both the healthcare and business communities. As CEO of UnitedHealthcare, Thompson held a prominent position in one of the nation’s largest health insurers. The motive behind the shooting remains unclear, but the charges indicate a high degree of premeditation.

Federal intervention in cases typically reserved for state prosecution is rare. However, when a crime meets the criteria for terrorism or threatens broader public safety, federal agencies sometimes step in to ensure maximum penalties. This approach would likely draw significant attention, especially if it leads to a federal death penalty case, a rarity in recent years.

Mangione’s fate now hinges on whether federal prosecutors decide the case merits their involvement. If the federal government steps in, the legal process and potential consequences will escalate significantly. For now, the extradition process and state charges are proceeding, but the door remains open for a far more severe federal prosecution.

MORE STORIES