In Toms River, New Jersey, a contentious dispute has arisen regarding religious freedom as the town council moves to seize the property of Christ Episcopal Church through eminent domain. The church had planned to build a 17-bed homeless shelter on its 11-acre property, but the town aims to repurpose the land for recreational facilities, including pickleball courts, a skate park, and a soccer field.
The council’s 4-3 vote on April 30 to initiate the seizure has drawn criticism from religious leaders and community members. The church’s attorney, Michael York, condemned the move, stating, “It is blatantly illegal, improper, and violates the United States Constitution, as well as numerous New Jersey laws and case law.”
Mayor Daniel Rodrick defended the decision, emphasizing the town’s need for recreational spaces. “It’s a great location,” he said. However, critics argue that the timing of the seizure, following the church’s shelter proposal, suggests retaliation against the church’s efforts to aid the homeless.
The Episcopal Diocese of New Jersey has expressed concern over the town’s actions. In a statement, The Rt. Rev. Sally French said, “I am troubled by the township’s move to block the faithful ministry of Christ Church, and I am saddened that the mayor and township council are prioritizing pickleball courts over responding to hunger and homelessness.”
Community members have rallied in support of the church, with over 5,600 people signing a petition opposing the town’s plan. The petition asserts, “Eminent domain should never be used to control a church’s ministries.”
The church’s rector, Rev. Lisa Hoffman, expressed disappointment over the town’s lack of communication, stating she learned about the vote from a parishioner the night before it occurred. As the town proceeds with its plans, legal challenges are expected, with the church and its supporters prepared to defend their constitutional rights.
