Following a deadly home invasion in Vaughan, Ontario, Chief MacSween addressed the public with safety guidance that quickly ignited controversy.
Speaking at a press conference, MacSween told residents:
“In the unlikely event that you find yourself the victim of a home invasion, we are urging citizens not to take matters into their own hands.
“While we don’t want homeowners to feel powerless, we urge you to call 9-1-1 and do everything you can to keep yourself and loved ones safe until police arrive and be the best witness possible. This could mean locking yourself in a room away from the perpetrators, hiding, fleeing the home, but don’t engage unless absolutely necessary.”
The comments were made after an intruder broke into a home in Vaughan and killed a resident. Just hours later, another break-in occurred nearby. MacSween’s statements were intended as general safety advice, but many Canadians and critics abroad interpreted them as a sign of law enforcement prioritizing criminal safety over citizens’ rights to defend themselves.
Critics argue the advice leaves law-abiding homeowners vulnerable. Multiple commentators noted that in countries like Canada, where strict gun control laws limit self-defense options, such messaging reflects a dangerous trend of encouraging submission instead of protection.
While MacSween did not explicitly say residents should allow themselves to be harmed, his remarks emphasized avoidance over resistance. This line of reasoning mirrors similar law enforcement guidance across Canada, where the right to self-defense is tightly restricted.
Supporters of the chief’s approach argue that non-engagement reduces the risk of violence. However, the reaction from many Canadians, particularly those in rural or high-crime areas, suggests deep unease with government officials discouraging personal defense in life-threatening situations.
In the United States, especially in conservative states, homeowners often have broad legal protections to use force, including firearms, when facing home invasions. In Canada, however, the legal system generally discourages armed resistance, even in one’s own home.
