California’s State Senate approved a bill co‑sponsored by Senator Scott Wiener that would prohibit federal Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) officers from wearing masks while on duty. The measure is now headed to Governor Gavin Newsom, who must decide whether to sign it into law.
Under the new legislation, ICE agents—and most law enforcement officers—would be required to appear unmasked during public operations, except in limited situations such as tactical missions or medical needs. The California Highway Patrol is exempt under the bill.
Supporters argue the bill advances transparency and accountability by ensuring that officers are identifiable. They say masked agents create fear and distrust among communities, especially during immigration enforcement actions.
Critics warn the law is unconstitutional, citing the Supremacy Clause which grants federal laws precedence over state laws. Some also claim it violates equal protection by exempting the Highway Patrol. Others argue the law could expose officers to danger or limit effectiveness in field operations where masks are necessary.
Senator Wiener has previously sponsored legislation seen as controversial, including efforts to soften loitering laws and expand access for transgender medical procedures. His critics say this bill is part of a broader pattern of enabling activists at the expense of law enforcement authority.
Governor Newsom now faces a political decision: whether to sign the bill and appease left‑leaning activists, or veto it to support federal agents and law enforcement agencies. The outcome could set a precedent for other states considering similar mask bans on law enforcement.
